April 23, 2018

In China, the questionable aesthetics of "refining" cities and getting rid of whatever is zangluancha.

By Zhou Wang (assistant professor at Nankai University’s Zhou Enlai School of Government) in Sixth Tone:
First, municipal officials have embraced the need to “refine” the country’s cities. From vast metropolises like Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangzhou to thousands of smaller Chinese cities, the same government-sponsored buzzwords appear: “high-end,” “aesthetically pleasing,” “cosmopolitan.” Chinese urban planners strive to realize socially positive notions of “modern” and “green” cities, and the most successful are recognized by government ministries in a series of competitions. Cities are also eager to earn national awards for being exceptionally clean or “civilized.”

Municipal officials define “refinement” in remarkably similar ways. Typically, it involves inviting a renowned international architect to design a capital-intensive landmark building — say, Zaha Hadid’s Guangzhou Opera House or Meinhard von Gerkan’s Chongqing Grand Theater. Officials may also clear huge public squares in front of municipal government buildings, construct avant-garde statues largely devoid of any local cultural or historical significance, and erect “central business districts” that resemble cut-and-pasted copies of the Manhattan skyline. The natural result of this is cities that are indistinguishable from one another, something that continues to be a source of public complaint.

“Refinement” also means clean urban environments, a sense of order, and standards for the appearance of residences and street advertisements... Urban managers don’t want their cities referred to as zangluancha — a colloquial term used for anything substandard that comprises the characters for “dirty,” “messy,” and “inferior.”...
ADDED: There's a link on zangluancha that goes to "My Mission to Clean Up China’s Atrocious Public Toilets" by the founder of an organization devoted to that mission:

The spectacular mountain views in Garzê Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture, in the southwestern Chinese province of Sichuan, seem deliberately designed to provide the greatest possible juxtaposition with the lamentable state of the area’s public toilets. A stone’s throw from the soaring peaks of the plateau, a few rudimentary pits have been dug into the ground, surrounded by ramshackle wooden planks for privacy and protection from the elements. The floorboards groan ominously underfoot, a nerve-wracking reminder of your proximity to an ignominious fall from grace....

Every year, Buddhist ceremonies are held in Garzê, during which the local population explodes from about 10,000 to 200,000 people. The hastily assembled men’s restrooms have no urinals, meaning devotees simply go for a number one outside. By the end of the festival, the whole mountain reeks of urine, and runoff from the soil endangers the local water supply — an environmental problem that is decidedly un-Buddhist.

In recent years, ever-greater numbers of Chinese tourists have visited Japan, a nation that has refined public conveniences into an art form....

29 comments:

rhhardin said...

Dictator hailing a cab statues have a future.

buwaya said...

To be fair, most of the "local cultural significance", that is the ancient architecture of Chinese towns, has long since been removed and replaced by some sort of concrete at some point after the 1950s. Many previous governments had their own ideas of "refining".

There is a very active preservationist-restorationist movement now though, and considerable internal tourism interested in it.

YoungHegelian said...

"Top Down" urban planning always begets disaster, no matter where it's practiced. "Top Down" anything in China always begets disaster.

gspencer said...

The Simpsons show us how to do it right,

https://78.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lgf2pj1UsF1qh59n0o1_r1_500.gif

Ralph L said...

The natural result of this is cities that are indistinguishable from one another
Non-cities have difficult distinguishing cities. It's been proven all cities look the same to them.

Ralph L said...

You lost the back end of your first tag, Althouse.

Nonapod said...

Officials may also clear huge public squares in front of municipal government buildings, construct avant-garde statues largely devoid of any local cultural or historical significance, and erect “central business districts” that resemble cut-and-pasted copies of the Manhattan skyline. The natural result of this is cities that are indistinguishable from one another, something that continues to be a source of public complaint.

Chinese urban engineering seems like a giant game of Sim City.

gspencer said...

"The natural result of this is cities that are indistinguishable from one another,"

Have yourself blindfolded and spin around n times until you're really, really dizzy; then allow yourself to be taken "somewhere" and be plunked down inside some US mall or some US major airport. Now guess where you are.

mccullough said...

Forget it Jake, they’re Chinatowns

mandrewa said...

serpentza: China: How it is: Tissues and Toilets

(What are all these bags of tissues all about? How and why do I use a Chinese toilet? What do they look like? How do you use them and how do you ask for the toilet?)

see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nGwK8lQej38

Char Char Binks, Esq. said...

They're gentrifying, so it's probably racist an sheeit.

Darrell said...

Trump can build it better and cheaper. And on time.

the 4chan Guy who reads Althouse said...

"There's a link on zangluancha that goes to "My Mission to Clean Up China’s Atrocious Public Toilets" by the founder of an organization devoted to that mission..."

So, does that, like, make China a shithole country?

Because fucked-up toilets would seem to make a place a shithole, I think.

I don't mean anything bad about the China people, I'm just talking about their fucked-up toilet paper and shit.

tcrosse said...

Because fucked-up toilets would seem to make a place a shithole, I think.

You could always shit on the sidewalk.

Sebastian said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
buwaya said...

San Francisco has atrocious public toilets.
Just to be fair.

Sebastian said...

To refine their cities, they would first have to cleanse them of the Communist Party.

Balfegor said...

Officials may also clear huge public squares in front of municipal government buildings, construct avant-garde statues largely devoid of any local cultural or historical significance, and erect “central business districts” that resemble cut-and-pasted copies of the Manhattan skyline.

They really don't much resemble the Manhattan skyline -- that's obviously just a stand-in for "generic high rise-city." Manhattan has more old skyscrapers than most other cities, other than perhaps Chicago, and that gives it a very different feel. If anything, the Chinese central business districts (at least the handful I've seen) remind me much more of LA than of New York, because of the car-traffic and the huge roads. Well, Shanghai is its own thing -- Lujiazui doesn't look like any place in the US or elsewhere, that I've seen.

Balfegor said...

re: buwaya:

San Francisco has atrocious public toilets.
Just to be fair.


I don't think this is mutually exclusive. Both Chinese and US cities can be shitholes. New York is a lot better than San Francisco (which is comically filthy -- there's a poopmap I would link to, but the creator is upset people keep using it to make fun of San Francisco), but it's pretty dirty too. On the other hand, without quite acknowledging that they have a serious problem, my subjective impression is that most US cities have actually been doing better at keeping public spaces clean than they were back in the 90s. Other than San Francisco. I think SF has gotten worse.

mandrewa said...

Chinese City Review - Guangzhou (Canton): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s1VQk_yw5wU

Chinese City Review - Beijing : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MY3o9NcCPFg

Chinese City Review - Dalian : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uba0aCFcMi8

JackWayne said...

This should provide relief to anyone thinking that China has our number. As YH points out, urban planning is on the downward slope of good governance.

mockturtle said...

4Chan, I also thought of 'shithole' in regard to 'zangluancha'. 'Shithole' is much easier to say.

buwaya said...

"I think SF has gotten worse."

Yes, "progressively" so since Frank Jordan was mayor, or 1996 thereabouts. About the last time they seriously tried to control the homeless.

HoodlumDoodlum said...

Tom Friedman's wet dream.

Refinement is usually a process of "burning away" unwanted portions. Seems like kind of a tricky concept to embrace in a society/nation that burned their way through tens of millions of (I guess) unwanted human beings.

Michael K said...

About ten or fifteen years ago the NY Times ran an article on a Chinese city named Orange County that had homes that looked exactly like Orange County CA homes but they had to build outdoor kitchens because Cunese cooking is so smokey.

great Unknown said...

No different than the "blight" justification for eminent-domain seizures in this country. Except that the Chinese version appears to be more honest and ethical.

whitney said...

The public toilets in Vietnam and Cambodia are unbelievably bad. And you have to pay for the pleasure of using them. Toilet paper not included

Clyde said...

This discussion brought to mind a scene from one of my favorite old movies, Demolition Man, from 1993. LANGUAGE WARNING! THIS YOUTUBE CLIP IS NSFW!

Demolition Man - The Three Seashells

Douglas B. Levene said...

"'Top Down' urban planning always begets disaster, no matter where it's practiced." Huh. Come visit Shenzhen. It's the richest city in China - by far. In the Nanshan District of Shenzhen, where most of the privately owned high tech firms are located, the per capita GDP is over US$50,000/year. So the city government has more money than it knows what to do with and they are spending it largely on making the city more beautiful, with great parks, public transport, roads and airports. They are not spending it on welfare transfer payments. That's smart urban planning.